The Journal of Modern Research on Administrative Law

The Journal of Modern Research on Administrative Law

Legal Analysis of the evolution of administrative system of the state registration for deeds and real state property based on judiciary evolution program

Document Type : Applied Articles

Authors
1 MA.Student in (The Law of Deeds and Real State Registration), Departmant Of Law, Faculty of Human Sciences,Imam Reza University, Mashhad, Iran.
2 Assistant Prof. Department Of Law, Faculty of Human Sciences,Imam Reza University, Mashhad, Iran.
10.22034/mral.2023.1970995.1391
Abstract
In any government, reforming the administrative policy in a way that makes it possible to achieve as many goals as possible is the main issue; And these developments have a double sensitivity towards the country's property and documents registration organization, as an authority for establishing the rights of individuals, considering its structural and functional position in establishing legal-judicial security. However, the results obtained from three decades of transformation programs have a significant difference compared to the intended goals. Therefore, considering the distinction between the managerial nature of the administrative system and the bureaucratic authority that governs the governing institutions, the main question is, what role and position do the rules of administrative law play as a result of the changes in the registration institution?



Regarding the research problem, in order to focus on the mutual influence of administrative law (basis) and administrative system (method), there is no background. Therefore, the current research has investigated the role of legal rules in the emergence of administrative problems and how to solve them using a descriptive-causal analysis method. The data collection in this study was done by documentary and field method. And the findings of the research indicate that, in general, the rules of administrative law, due to defects and omissions in the supervision of diagnostic qualifications, have acted in the opposite way in the implementation position, therefore, the solutions presented with the approach of solving the problem of supervision, imply the realization goals will be.

Highlights

 

Legal analysis of  the evolution of administrative system of the state registration for deeds and real state property based on judiciary evolution program

 

 

In the 20-year vision document of the Islamic Republic of 1404, the Iranian society is depicted as a society with social justice and legal-judicial security. And in the general policies announced for Article 44 of the Constitution, it is emphasized on the sovereign supervision over the implementation of the relevant laws without interfering in the executive affairs. According to the important position and basic role of the organization of documents and real estate registration of the country, the plans compiled in the administrative transformations of this organization must ensure the realization of the organization's internal and external transformation goals.

The current research was conducted in an interdisciplinary legal-management way and in a causal descriptive-analytical method; The information required in this study has been collected through documentary studies (research literature), field studies (questionnaires) and elite interviews, and in two discourses, the root complication is found in the context of legal rules, and then with the approach of optimization and elimination of the cause of occurrence. Obstacles are addressed to the institutional mapping of the transformation plan in the organization.
The purpose of this research is to formulate optimal and efficient mechanisms in organizational and extra-organizational transformations. However, achieving this goal requires answering the question of what role and place do the rules of administrative law play in the results of the organization's administrative transformations?

The findings of the research show that the legal rules as a functional basis in the administration of affairs have raised generalities and the administrative bureaucracy has become one of the efficient obstacles of the administrative system due to legal formalism. The neglect and neglect of the administrative decision-making authority, from the spirit and purpose of the law, has led to conflict of interests and its escalation. For example:

According to the sixth and eighth chapters of the Civil Service Management Law approved in 2016, leaving the organizations free to apply their selection regulations and giving the authority to determine the specialized conditions of professional managers and the amount of necessary acquired points and required employment experience, to the executive body itself, which should only approval of the Supreme Administrative Council; It leads to the taste of examples of meritocracy and causes the intensification of organizational politicization.

And also, according to the eighth and fifth chapters of the Civil Service Management Law, the supervision of the administrative bureaucracy will be limited to observing the maximum allowed in the relevant cases and through the superior authority. This procedure will contribute significantly to the occurrence of maximum bureaucracy, inflation of the organizational body, and false wealth.

Taking into account the bureaucratic authority governing government institutions, this regulatory defect has overshadowed the organization's performance in an organizational and extra-organizational way, so that according to field information, the performance of the document registration organization in a holistic view depends on two issues of the interest rate. People and the quality of the administrative system, which the desirability of registration services with a score of 21.875 out of 100 and the quality of the administrative system with a score of 23.2 out of 100, indicate a significant gap between the organization's performance and the organizational and extra-organizational goals of this institution.

Finding the root of the problems counted by the method of five levels, why?, revealed that the problem of the lack of quality of the administrative system of the registration institution is rooted in the general policies of supervision, and consequently it will cause conflicts of interest, and the problem of the lack of desirability of registration services is rooted in extra-organizational policies. and has led to lack of information transparency.

And according to what was determined from the Judiciary transformation document, the two characteristics of being a leader and central participation in performance are the basis for formulating transformation strategies in subordinate organizations. On the one hand, the ultimate goal of the changes is to fight corruption and make the administrative system more efficient; And since the lack of transparency of information and the occurrence of conflicts of interest are among the main reasons listed for the occurrence of corruption, the strategies of SWAT, based on the calculated factors in order to achieve the goals, can be considered as follows:

 

 

4 strategies of SWAT

 


Strengths: (performance capacity, penetration coefficient, , performance style, independence level, performance efficiency)

Weaknesses: (performance capacity, performance method, information architecture, financial burden of performance, effectiveness of performance)

 

opportunity:

(digital literacy, technology development, transformational approach, systemic value, cognitive quality)

 

 

Offensive strategy:

Smartening to make the administrative system more efficient

 

 

Adaptive strategy:

People-centered for the comprehensiveness and dynamism of the information bank

 

Threats: (Normal relations, functional competitors, financial resources

, Terms and Conditions

organizational risk)

 

contingency strategy:

Intelligence to manage conflicts of interest

 

Defensive strategy:

Organizational and trans-organizational synergy for information transparency

 



 

 

Keywords
Subjects

  • References:

    Persian books:

    • Alvani,M.and Hamed Mohammadi. The Fundamentals Of Public Managment. First Ed. Babol:Mabas 2011
    • A and Ahmad Markazmalmiri. The concept and scope of the general principles of administrative law; The possibility and how to invoke it in judicial proceedings. Second Ed.Tehran: Judiciary Publishing Center.2019
    • Robbins, Stephen P. Organization theory: structure, design and applications . Alvani,M and Hasan Danayifard .16th Tehran: Safar.2007
    • M.J , Administrative Law(1). Third Ed. Tehran: Mizan 2017
    • Marty, M.D. “Large systems of criminal politics”. 4th Tehran:Mizan. 2019
    • Vaezi, M. Administrative Law(1). First Ed. Tehran: Mizan Legal Foundation.2021

    Latin books:

    • Rudiarto, I, "Corruption on Land Use Planning and Land Registration-Cadastre Process: An Analysis of Causes and Consequences," : LAP LAMBERT Academic Publishing, 2010 ,page 23.

    Persian  Articles:

     

    • Abrosh,R and ali jaberi.” Market control strategies in Imam Ali's biography Journal of Islamic government.79,2016
    • Palizdar,K and Ebrahim Chirani and Mozafar Mirbargkar and Kambiz Shahroodi. “The Mediating Role of Information Transparency in Reducing Economic Corruption in the E-commerce space of the country” .IAAR.49.2021
    • Khaji, M.”he necessity of using the capacity of institutional mapping in public policies”.Hekmatane magazine.15.2018
    • Gorji, A. “The rule of law in the legal system of the Islamic Republic of Iran: feasibility study of a theory “. Legal research Quarterly. 48, 2009
    • Khadivi,A and alireza Farid, “Conceptual review of digital literacy”. Jornal of Managment, Economics & Enterpreeurship.3,2021
    • Khorshid,S and Reza RanjBar.”Strategic analysis, formulation and strategy selection based on SWAT matrix and fuzzy multi-indicator decision making techniques”. Journal of Strategic Managment in Industrial Systems.12.2010
    • Political Studies Office of Islamic Council Research Center.”Politicization of administrative institutions and providing solutions for the Islamic Republic of Iran (case study of Pakistan, China, England)”.2011
    • Riahi, N.” The position of the country's document and real estate registration organization in Iran's separation of powers system”. Journal of Law(University pf Isfahan).8.2018.
    • Salehi, J.” administrative corruption; The concept of its causes and effects” . Kanoon. 102,2009.
    • Tabatabayi Hesari, Nasrin. “A comparative study of the position of the real estate registration organization in the governance structure; Integration into the "judicial system" or "executive system" and the government body”. Comp Law Rev,1.2018
    • Abedi Aedakani,M and Loghman Soltani. “ The relationship between the administrative system and the political development of the Islamic Republic of Iran (using Jaguraib's theory)” Pol Quar.54.2019
    • Farhadian,Ali and ali Bahadori Jahromi.” The impact and impression of efficient management and citizen rights; Considering the internal administrative rules” . 30.2021
    • Katoozian,A.N. “Judicial policy and notary offices” .JFLPS. 68. 2004
    • Kamalizade,M. “Efficient bureaucracy from the perspective of institutionalism”Two Quarterly Journals of Theoretical Policy Research. 2015
    • Gorji Azandaryani, A and Farzin Ghahramanzadh Nimgazi.” Examining the control of bureaucratic authority in the context of bureaucratic relations, politics and efficiency”. 50.2016
    • Mazaheri,E. “ Intangible assets accounting procedures and upcoming challenges” 9.2014
    • Hemati,A." Information architecture in administrative system". Tahavol-e-Edari. 2005
    • Yousefpour,B.” Improving employees through the use of administrative automation” Management in the Islamic world. 5.2019

    Latin Articles:

    • Baek ,A and Karen Whitehill King "Exploring the consequences of brand credibility in services " ,Journal of Services Marketing 25,2011

    The law:

    • Executive letter for the realization of electronic government,
    • Iran constitution, 1977
    • Deeds and Real State Registration Law, 1937
    • Notary Low, 1975
    • Civil Service Management Law, 2007.

    Electronic resources:

    • Imna, The subject of 70% of the legal cases of the courts , Available at imna.ir/news/ 503424 , last Visited 2021.
    • Raimand Knowledge Base Company. The difference between GPS and GNSS -. Available at net . last Visited 2021

    Judicial opinion

    • The decision of the General Board of the Court of Administrative Justice, No obligation to prepare the vehicle document in notary offices, Nom 9804185 / 2020.
    • Opinion No, 2655, 1988, Guardian Council.
    • Opinion No, 2664, 2016, Guardian Council.

     

Volume 5, Issue 17
Fifth year, 17th issue, Winter 2023
Autumn 2023
Pages 336-365

  • Receive Date 19 October 2022
  • Revise Date 01 March 2023
  • Accept Date 18 March 2023