The Journal of Modern Research on Administrative Law

The Journal of Modern Research on Administrative Law

The analysis of changing the employment type of war veterans from corporate employees to officially hired employees with emphasis on the administrative justice court decision.

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 PhD Student in Public Law, Qom Branch, Islamic Azad University, Qom, Iran
2 Assistant Professor of Law, Shahed University, Tehran, Iran
3 Member of the Faculty of Public Law, Baqer al-Uloom University
Abstract
Abstract;

Right to work (employment) is one of the most important right, classified in the second generation of human right, has been emphasized in article 23 of the universal declaration of human right and has been recognized as one of the economic, social and culeural right in article 20of Islamic republic of Iran constitution.The necessity of equal terms in employment also has been mentioned in article 28 of Islamic republic of Iran constitution.Therefore lack of unreasonable diversity of employment contract is one of the issues discussed in hiring systems. Due to this matter, employment form change is one of the most emportant issues in employment law and a prerequisite for job safety and right to employment.This research, which has been conducted through an analytical-descriptive approach, aims to analyze the regulations of employing corporate employees and changing their type to officially employed. It also answers the question of whether all corporate employees are entitled to petition to have their type changed to officially employed.The answer is that the government is required to officially employ those corporate employees who are liable to clause 21 of the general law of serving war veterans and have been hired during the period when the fifth five-years-long development plan was in practice,according to the stipulated terms in the article and clause 44 of the aforementioned law and the subsequent revisions.This possibility has been predicted in article of cluse 87 of the law of the sixth five-years-long development plan.

Keywords:Corporate employees,Formal employment,Status change,Employment, Court of Administrative Justice.

Highlights

Changing the employment type is complicated and ambiguous by nature and perhaps this is why law exerts have not suggested a clear and comprehensive definition in this respect yet. Changing the employment type can suggest different interpretations, however an all-embracing definition that can be suggested is as follows; “ changing the employment type of corporate employees hired by the government can be applied if these employees are eligible in terms of knowledge, personal and institutional conduct as well as religious criteria, have expertise, enthusiasm, creativity and innovation, the sense of responsibility and service, punctuality and observing administrative regulations, have taken on-job training courses and achieved the require score, have been qualified according to the ground rules and regulations such as availability of legal permission (                                                       ) and in some cases availability of related vacant positions, have taken examinations based on equal opportunities. This includes changing from corporate employee to contractual employee, from contractual employee to hired employee, from hired employee to officially employed, from officially employed to probationary official employment and from probationary to peremptory official employment.

The juridical characteristic of changing employment type can be different depending on which type is changed to which type. Sometimes this type of conversion can be considered as a contract which is different from a private law contact. One important consideration in this regard is that if the type is changed the employee-establishment relation is determined by decree, but in this case the stage prior to establishment of this type must be considered. In some other cases the type is change according to the law and the establishment changes the employment type unilaterally and without the employee`s petition.

Executive establishments recruit their staff directly from officially employed individuals, hire employees and contractual employees and indirectly from corporate employees. Corporate employees are considered to be under non-governmental employers and executive establishments are not held responsible towards these employees.

According to clauses 10 and 12 of procedure and constitution of the administrative justice court, the cognizable authority where employment lawsuits should be alleged is the administrative justice court, especially lawsuits of employment type change.

Eventhough changing the employment type of corporate employees was possible at different points, this is currently available for corporate employees who are liable to clause 21 of the general law of serving war veterans and were recruited during the period that the fifth five-years-long development plan was in practice and have the requirements mentioned in the article and clause 44 of the aforementioned law and the subsequent revisions. This possibility has been predicted in article “D” of clause 87 of the law of the sixth five-years-long development plan.

There are some points denoting that, firstly, this type change is not considered as employment type change since according to clause 45 of the law of governmental administration, legally valid employment specifically means only official and contractual employment. Secondly, the employees have to be recruited during the period of the fifth five-years-long development plan. Thirdly, the employment type change is available for only war veterans. Finally, of all types of employment, only changing employment type from probationary to peremptory official employment is possible and employment type change is not possible for those employees in any other types. Those employees who have been recruited during the period of the sixth five-years-long development plan and based on clause 21 of the general law of serving war veterans can petition to have their employment type changed to peremptory official employment. In order to corroborate this regulation, article 4 term 20 of the budget legislation of the year 1400 (2021-2022) was enacted which removed all the ambiguities of changing employment type of these employees. Recruiting and changing the employment type of corporate employees will lead to the increase in the number of the government associates and in turn enlargement of the government. Additionally, recruiting these employees in institutional positions leads to

Keywords
Subjects

Abolhamad, Abdolhamid, Administrative Law of Iran, Tehran, Toos, 2009
Emami, Mohammad, Kourosh Ostvar Sangari, Administrative Law, Tehran, Mizan, 2010
Sohrabloo, Ali, Hassan Lotfi, Transformation of Employment Status in Iranian Law, Nature and Principles: Scientific Quarterly of Judicial Law Perspectives, Summer 1400, No. 94, pp. 73-93
Tabatabai Motameni, Manouchehr, Administrative Law, Tehran: Samat, 2016
Fekouhi, Nasser, Mechanism of Positive Discrimination, as a Tool of Deprivation: Women's Research, Fall 2005, No. 3, pp. 115-141
Qafi, Hossein, The Nature and Validity of the Supplementary Agreement: Journal of Islamic Law, Fall 2004, No. 42, Pages 61 to 88
Karami, Hamed, Mehdi Goodarzi, Legal Analysis of the Contract for Purchasing Services of Employees of Executive Bodies with Emphasis on the Opinions of the Court of Administrative Justice: Quarterly Journal of Modern Administrative Law Research, Fall 99, No. 4, pp. 79-106
Mashhadi, Ali, Dictionary of Administrative Law Terms, Tehran: Anteshar Co., 1397
Universal Declaration of Human Rights
International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights
3- Philadelphia Declaration
4- The Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Iran
5- The vision document of the Islamic Republic of Iran in 1404
6- General employment policies dated 1/2/2010
7- Law on definitions and criteria for establishing research centers approved on 1/21/1369
National employment law approved on 31/3/1345
Civil Service Management Law approved on 8/7/1386
Law on Employment Regulations of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, approved on 7/21/1370
Law on employment of law enforcement
Law on reviewing the competence of judges
The law of the fourth five-year development plan of the Islamic Republic of Iran
Law of the Fifth Five-Year Development Plan of the Islamic Republic of Iran
Law of the Sixth Five-Year Development Plan of the Islamic Republic of Iran
Law on Adding Articles to the Law on Regulation of a Part of Government Financial Regulations - approved in 2005
Statute of Farhangian University
Law on Employment and Social Facilities for Veterans of the Islamic Revolution, approved on 6/26/1368
Law of the Sixth Five-Year Development Plan of the Islamic Republic of Iran
Budget Law of 1400
Labor law
Resolution of the Supreme Council of the Cultural Revolution entitled "How to hire new faculty members of the medical department and change the status of the staff" approved on 11/6/1365
The executive by-law of the law on how to adjust the manpower of government agencies
Executive regulations of Article 22 of the Civil Service Management Law
Resolution No. 84515 / T34613 of the Council of Ministers dated 15/12/1384
Instructions for determining the task and how to directly employ the forces working in companies
Approval No. 77961 / T40006 of the Council of Ministers dated 5/17/1387
Circular No. 100/135938 dated 17/8/1385 of the Management and Planning Organization
Circular No. 85905/60 of the Vice President for Management and Human Capital Development dated 12/9/1387
Resolution of the Council of Ministers No. 43310 / T42450 AH dated 13/2/1388
Circular No. 28298/200 of the Vice President for Development and Human Capital dated 9/11/2011
Resolution No. 213471 / T47643 of the Council of Ministers dated 1/11/2011
Resolution No. 107441 / T44444 of the Council of Ministers dated 28/5/2012
Resolution No. 176441 / T48702 of the Council of Ministers dated 9/21/2012 (Mehrafarin plan)
Circular No. 83003 dated 7/21/2015 of the Deputy Head of Management Development and Industries of the country's airports company
Letter No. 9000/330/6932/200 dated 16/9/1399 of the Court of Administrative Justice
Commentary No. 583/21/76 dated 10/3/1997 of the Guardian Council
Questionnaire Note 1 Paragraph D of Article 87 of the Law on the Sixth Five-Year Economic, Social and Cultural Development Plan of the Islamic Republic of Iran, dated 3/10/1398
Letter of the Speaker of the Assembly to No. 67794 AH / B dated 9/11/2012
Theory No. 15074 AH / B of the Speaker of the Parliament dated 31/3/1391
Letter of the Speaker of the Parliament to No. 111/10874 dated 2/3/1388
Lawsuit No. 849-874 of the General Assembly of the Court of Administrative Justice dated 11/14/1392
Lawsuit No. 466 of the General Assembly of the Court of Administrative Justice dated 5/17/1396
Lawsuit No. 15 and 51 of the General Assembly of the Court of Administrative Justice dated 21/1/1397
Lawsuit No. 2163-2164 of the General Assembly of the Court of Administrative Justice dated 21/12/1397
Lawsuit No. 1849-1851 of the General Assembly of the Court of Administrative Justice dated 9/20/1397
Lawsuit No. 669 of the General Assembly of the Court of Administrative Justice dated 11/4/1398
 
 
Volume 4, Issue 10 - Serial Number 10
Fourth Year, 10th Issue , Spring 2022
Spring 2022
Pages 177-206

  • Receive Date 16 November 2021
  • Revise Date 03 December 2021
  • Accept Date 18 December 2021