The Journal of Modern Research on Administrative Law

The Journal of Modern Research on Administrative Law

Evaluation of the Legislative Effects of the Guardian Council's Approach to the Jurisdictions of the Administrative Justice Court

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 PhD in Public Law & Judge of Administrative Justice Court, Tehran, Iran
2 Assistant Prof., Department of International Law, Faculty of Law and Political Science, University of Kharazmi, Tehran, Iran
Abstract
Following the interpretation of the Guardian Council on the principle of 170 of the Constitution in 1383, due to the overcoming of verbal interpretation in the Council, the jurisdiction of the Administrative Justice Court became one of the points of the Islamic Parliament and the Guardian Council. Due to Parliament's insistence on some of its approvals, the Expediency Council also engaged in this dispute that the Assembly also adopted the interstitial decisions. The purpose of this paper is to investigate the effects of the Guardian Council approach to the jurisdiction of the Court and the options of pre-assembly and assembly in the face of the mentioned approach. It should be noted that despite researches done about the limits of the jurisdictions of the Administrative Justice Court, no independent research has been done on this subject. This essay, with a descriptive-analytic method, seeks to identify and evaluate the above options. Based on the findings of this study, the generalization of the Administrative Justice Court to all administrative disputes, although desirable, but it requires constitutional amendment, and in the current situation it may not be expedient. In this situation, with the approval of the Parliament and the approval of the Assembly, deviating from the approach of the Guardian Council and generalizing the jurisdiction of the Administrative Justice Court to the necessary cases enumerated in this article, it seems a more justified option.
Keywords
Subjects

1. aghaee Toogh, Muslem and Hassan Lotfi (1398), Administrative Law 1, Tehran, Anteshar Co.

2. Ostvar Sangari, Kourosh (1398), Legal Government, Tehran, Mizan Publishing.

3. Emami, Mohammad and Kourosh Ostovarsangari, (2007), Administrative Law, Tehran, Mizan Publishing, Volume One.

4. Ghamami, Majid and Hassan Mohseni (2017), Transnational Procedure, Tehran, Anteshar Co.

5. Molabigi, Gholamreza (2014), Jurisdiction and Procedure of the Court of Administrative Justice, Tehran: Jungle and Immortal.

6. Najab Takhva, Morteza (2011), The Law of the Court of Administrative Justice in the Current Legal Order, Tehran, Jangal and immortal.

7. Mr. Toogh, Muslim) «,) 1398 Historical analysis on the duality of the process of handling liability claims
The Side of Government in Iranian Law ", Quarterly Journal of Public Law Research, Volume 21, Number 62, pp. 265 - 243.

8. Parvin, Khairullah and others) «,) 1398 Jurisdiction of the Court of Administrative Justice in privatization cases Services and Public Goods ", Quarterly Journal of Administrative Law, Volume 7, Number 21, pp. 80-57.

9. Jalali, Mohammad and others) «,) 1396 Separation of jurisdiction of the Court of Administrative Justice and the General Court in lawsuits Civil Liability Against the Government ”, Legal Journal of Justice, Vol. 81, No. 99, pp. 112-85.

10. Raji, Seyed Mohammad Hadi and Mohammad Amin Abrisham Yarad (1397) Reflections on the Jurisdiction of the Assembly
Recognition of the expediency of the system in approving enactments contrary to the constitution ", Quarterly Journal of Public Law Studies,
No. 3, pp. 523 - 507.

11. Mahmoudi, Javad) «,) 2005 A reflection on the interpretive theory of the Guardian Council about the powers of the Court Administrative Justice ", Journal of Constitutional Rights, Year 3, Number 5, pp. 405 - 387.

12. Hemmati, Mojtaba) «,) 2016 The right of access to justice in the Court of Administrative Justice with a look at the comments Guardian Council ", Quarterly Journal of Public Law Knowledge, No. 16, pp. 128 - 103.
Volume 2, Issue 2
Second year, second issue, spring 2020
Spring 2020
Pages 95-116

  • Receive Date 13 April 2020
  • Revise Date 02 May 2020
  • Accept Date 16 June 2020