The Journal of Modern Research on Administrative Law

The Journal of Modern Research on Administrative Law

Challenges of the supervision of supreme audit court on the universities of the Ministry of Science

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 buali sina university
2 Master of Public Law. Department of law, Faculty of humanities, Bu-Ali Sina University, Hamadan, Iran
10.22034/mral.2023.2002337.1468
Abstract
Investigation of the supervision of the supreme audit court on the universities of the Ministry of Science.The need to adapt to the increasing developments of knowledge has caused universities in many countries of the world to have independence with different degrees in administrative and financial issues. One of the methods of granting independence to universities is their administration by the Board of Trustees. The administration of the Board of Trustees in practice and during the implementation of their resolutions may face major problems due to inconsistencies or even contradictions with other laws and regulations and may be challenged by regulatory bodies such as the supreme audit court. This article uses a descriptive-analytical method and examines the rulings of the Administrative Justice Court and the procedure of the supreme audit court to answer the question of what ambiguities and challenges the supreme audit court faces in supervising universities. Among the ambiguities examined, we can mention the inconsistency between the law of the University Board of Trustees and other laws, different understanding of the laws, and difficulty in finding the offender.
Keywords
Subjects

Book
Abbasi, Esmail, The legal system and rules governing university property, Tehran: Publication of the Institute of Cultural and Social Studies.2021
Faraj Vand, Esfandiar, From Budget Regulation to Control, Tehran: Forozesh Publishing House, 2014.
 Mahmoudi, Javad, Legal System of Iranian Universities, Tehran: Mezan Publishing, 2015.
Mehraram, Parham, Badie Fathi, Academic governance: a comparative study in American, German and Iranian law (with an emphasis on judicial procedure), Tehran: Jangal Publications, 2016.
Mouszadeh, Reza, Administrative Law (1-2) Generalities and Iran, Tehran: Mezan Publishing, 2017.
Rostami, Vali, Hamid Kafhchian, Computational Financial Law, Tehran: Dadgstar Publications, 2016.
Rostami, Vali, Public Finance, Tehran: Mizan Publications, 2012, second edition
Sultan Niya, Akbar, review of 110 disicion issued by the advisory boards of the National Audit Office, published by the Education and Planning Center of the National Audit Office,2021
 
article
 
Azargashb Eznollah. Hamidreza Hamidreza Arasteh Hamidreza Arasteh . Zahra Sabaghian . Jafar Towfighi  .An Evaluation of Boards of Trustees’ Functions in Public Universities Affiliated to Ministry of Science, Research, and Technology (1991-2006) Research and Planning in Higher Education . Volume 13, Issue 4 - Serial Number 46
March 2008. Pages 1-20
Banaei Oskooei . Majid . Legal Position of Resolutions Drafted by Board of Trustees of Universities and Educational Institutions. Public Law Research. Volume 17, Issue 47 - Serial Number 47 October 2015 Pages 35-69
 Farhani, Ali Akbar, Seyyed Haider Hosseini, Management Leadership in Universities, Management Studies Quarterly, 2018, , No. 27
jamali. shadi  Comparative study of government-university relationship In Iran during the second Pahlavi period and after the victory of the Islamic Revolution.journal of social science.  Volume 11, Issue 39 - Serial Number 39 March 2018 .Pages 187-220
Keske, Shahab, Youssef Mohibzadegan, Strategic Development of Universities Explanation of Functional Elements of Board of Trustees and Trend Analysis of Function & Combination, Social Development and Welfare Planning. Volume 2, Issue 5 January 2011. Pages 165-202
Kodkhodaei, Abbas Ali, Seyyed Mohammad Tabatabainejad, Ali Fatahi Zafarqandi, Qualification of the State’s Supreme Audit Court in Financial Supervision on Public Non-Governmental Institutions, Quarterly Journal of Public Law Knowledge, Volume 8, Issue 23 - Serial Number 23. June 2019Pages 19-42
 Mehdi, Reza, Aznullah Azargashb, Administration of the Board of Trustees in Iran's Higher Education System, Higher Education Research and Planning Quarterly, 2016, Volume 23, Number 3.
Mohammadnejad, Yusuf, Rahmatullah Qalipour, an analysis of the performance of the Board of Trustees of Universities and Higher Education Institutions, Majlis Research Center, 2016, Report of Cultural Office
Moradkhani, Fardin, Farshid Bande Ali, The jurisdiction of the country's court of computation for protecting bait "Looking at the role of the Court in municipality supervisio, Administrative Law Quarterly, 2018, Volume Six, Number 16
Shariat, Bahauddin, an analysis of the performance of the board of trustees in the higher education system, Higher Education Research and Planning Quarterly, 1373, No. 7. 8.
Sharif, Mohammad, the legal position of the Supreme Council of the Cultural Revolution and the order of its approvals, Public Law Research, 2014, No. 15
Special, Mohammadreza, Fatemeh Afshari, Islamic Azad University, public or private institution? Shiraz Legal Studies Journal. Volume 6, Issue 4 - Serial Number 4
March 2015. Pages 183-214
Zakersalehi, Gholamreza, A comparative study of university management and leadership structure: A case study of the Board of Trustees, Journal of Iranian Higher Education Country of publication, 2015, Year 8, Number 3.
Zarei, Mohammad Hossein, Seyyed Mohammad Hosseini, Mohammad Najafi Kalyani, The Supreme Council of Cultural Revolution in the Scale of the Independence of Powers, journal legal studies, Volume 11, Issue 3 - Serial Number 33 December 2019 Pages 105-141
 
Law
Terms and Conditions The Law on Objectives, Duties and Organizations of the Ministry of Science, Research and Technology approved in 2014
The fifth five-year development plan law approved in 2019
Law of the Sixth Five-Year Development Plan 2016
Law of the Fourth Development Plan of J. A. A. approved in 2014
The Law on the Formation of the Board of Trustees of Universities and Higher Education and Research Institutions, approved in 1989
Law of the Court of Accounts approved in 1983
Law of the Board of Trustees of State Educational Institutions approved in 1972
Budget subtraction report for 2014
The single article of the administration of universities, approved by the Revolutionary Council in 1980
Financial and transaction regulations of universities approved in 2014
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Volume 6, Issue 19
Sixth year, 19th issue, Summer 2024
Spring 2024
Pages 133-163

  • Receive Date 17 May 2023
  • Revise Date 05 November 2023
  • Accept Date 21 November 2023