The ILlegal Results of Ideological Competences of the Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance for Artists and Cultural-Artistic Works

Document Type : Original Article

Author

Assistant Prof., Department of Public and International Law, Faculty of Law and Political Science, Allame Tabatabaee University, Tehran, Iran

Abstract

In non- secular governments, access to all aspects of citizens' life style is a principle that takes place in topics such as interference and guidance. What is happening in the field of culture, and in fact, the relationship between government and art, in the form of the existence of the ministry, for culture and art, which also exists in Iran, after the victory of the Islamic Revolution. This study was conducted with the aim of determining the government's approach to culture and art, and examining the behavior and performance of officials of the Ministry. Following the effects of the existence of this ministry in Iran, which has not been investigated from a legal point of view, in the light of the government's approach and the ministry's competences, it was concluded that the objectives and duties of the Ministry of Culture act, determined the way of this intervention, and considering the legal competences, this ministry has not been neutral, and support ideological culture and art it has the mission of this ministry. The Ministry, in addition to the positive effects that it has, in the field of performance, has left its own undesirable and practical effects, on works of art and artists, which can be placed in These topics: polarization of the artistic space, negative impact on artistic taste and creativity, discrimination among artists, highlighting officials instead of artists, enlarging the government, increasing negative bureaucracy, discriminating in obtaining facilities and ministry officials , To legal realism and pragmatism.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

Etemadi Fariborz 1999, Dr. Mohajerani from vote of confidence to impeachment, Tehran, Elm Publications.
Barbier Maurice 2007, Political Modernity, Translated by Abdolvahab Ahmadi, Tehran, Agah Publications.
Berlin Isaiah 1979, Four Articles about Freedom, Translated by Mohammad Ali Movahed, Tehran, Kharazmi.
Bashirieh Hossein 2007, Teaching Political knowledge, Tehran, Negah Moaser Publications.
Bonyadi Naeini Ali and et al 2010, History and evolution of organization and structure of Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance during recent 100 years, Research Center of Culture,  Art and Communication, Vol.1.
Pourostad Majid 2012, Role of civil judge on obtaining reason and discovering truth, Tehran, Shahre Danesh Publications.
Plamenatz John 1994, Ideology, Translated by Ezatollah Fouladvand, Tehran, Scientific and Cultural Publications.
Pir ataei Ali 2009, Theory of administration of contract, Tehran, Ghoghnous Publications.
Hariri Nasser 2002, About art and literature, A conversation with Masoumeh Seihon, Babol, Avishan Publications.
Heydari Gholam 1997, Introducing and criticizing films of Mohsen Makhmalbaf, Tehran, Negah Publications.
Rasekh Mohammad 2008, Freedom, truth and justice, Set of articles about of philosophy of law, right and value, Tehran, Tarhe No Vol.2.
Rasekh Mohammad 2010, Press and democracy: freedom, but ethics, Research center of human rights and scientific association of law students of University of Tehran, Set of articles for conference of press law, Tehran, Faculty of law and political sciences of University of Tehran. 
Rawls John 2013, Justice as fairness, Translated by Erfan Sabeti, Tehran, Ghoghnous Publications.
Reidy David A 2013, On the Philosophy of law, translated by Hassan Khosravi, Tehran, Majd publications.
Sari Fereshteh 2001, Forough Farokhzad, famous persons of 20th century, Iran, Tehran, Gheseh Publications, Vol.4.
Sattari Jalal 2000, Culture without state, a look toward some cultural and artistic activities at final years of previous regime of Iran, Tehran, Markaz Publications.
Salimi Hossein 2003, Cultural policy making, Policy making and culture in Iran(Set of articles), Tehran, Center for recognizing Iran and Islam, Research center of culture, art and communication.
Salehi Amiri Seyed Reza and Azimi Dolat Abadi, Amir 2008, Fundamentals of policy-making and cultural planning, Tehran, Strategic research center of Expediency Discernment Council.
Falah Zadeh Ali Mohammad 2012, Separation legislation and execution: Analyzing domains of legislative qualification for relations of legislative and executive powers, Tehran, Research center of Guardian Council.
Katouzian Nasser 2008, Responsible state instead of sovereignty state, A step toward justice(Set of articles), Tehran, Faculty of law and political sciences of University of Tehran, Vol.1.
Katouzian Nasser 2007, Fundamentals of public law, Tehran, Mizan Publications.
Keivanfar Shahram 2009, Legal realism, Set of articles submitted to Katouzian Nasser, Tehran, University of Tehran
Lucie Smith Edward 2008, Movements in art since 1945:issues and concepts, Translated by Alireza Sami Azar, Tehran, Nazar Publications.
Levy-Bruhl Henri 2007, sociology of law, Translated by Seyyed Abolfazl Ghazi, Tehran, Mizan Publications.
Mohammadzadeh Mohammad Jafar and et al 2013, A semi-look to performance of 9th government from (July 2005 to Apr 2005), Tehran, Deputy of Communication and Information of Presidential Office.
Movahed Mohammad Ali 2005, In search of right and justice: From natural right to human rights, Tehran, Karnameh publications.
Moore Barrington 1996, Social origins of dictatorship and democracy (lord and peasant in the Making of the Modern World), translated by Hossein Bashirieh, Tehran, Daneshgahi Publication Center.
Mohandespour Farhad 2009, Why independence is not main problem of theater in Iran? Sets of articles for seminar on private theater in Iran, Tehran, Namayesh Publications. 
Noushin Abdolhosein, 1952, theater, Tehran.
Vahid Majid 2003,Introduction: From culture of policy making to cultural policy making, Policy making and culture in Iran(Set of articles), Tehran, Center for recognizing Iran and Islam in research center of culture, art and communication.
Vincent Andrew 2008, Theories of the state, Translated by Hossein Bashirieh, Tehran, Nei publications.
Ashouri Daryoush 1992, Ideology, ethics and culture, Kelk, Issue.32-33, pp 42-58.
Agah Vahid 2019, Artistic or without art? Analyzing of artistic rights in charter on citizens right and its manifest, bioethics journal, Special issue on human rights and citizenship rights, pp.368-382.
Amiri Esfandougheh Morteza 2009, Iran is the land of sovereignty of poem, not governmental poem, A conversation with scientific secretary of Fajr poem festival, Window Journal, Issue.27, pp.72-73.
Bakhshi Masoud 2013, When we are saying FF, what do we mean? Bahar, p.12.
Habibi Hassan 1983, Notes about art, Artistic quarterly periodical, Issue.3, pp.38-41.
Rasekh Mohammad and Rafiei Mohammad Reza 2010, Ratio of government with good life: Attitude toward neutrality approach, Islamic law and jurisprudence, Issue.1, pp.109-131.
Rasekh Mohammad and Rafiei Mohammad Reza 2010, Ratio of government with good life: Attitude toward perfectionism approach, Islamic law and jurisprudence, Issue.1, pp.59-76.
Rasekh Mohammad and Rafiei Mohammad Reza 2010, Ratio of government with good life: Analyzing of neutrality and perfectionism approaches, Islamic law and jurisprudence, Issue.1, pp.61-99.
Ravdrad Azam and Asad zadeh Mostafa 2010, Political sociology in cinema of Iran, Cultural Research journal, Issue.9, p.57-88.
Soltani Kazem 1993, Cinema of Iran in search of values(A conversation with several members of cultural department of Farabi), Art and architecture, Issue.23, p.125-152.
Salimi Hossein 2007, The only way of Institutionalize of theater in Iran, Sahneh, Issue.42, p.8-14.
Shahabi Mehdi and Nikouei Marzieh 2012, Metaphysical law, Studying role of value on process of establishing legal rule, Legal studies, Issue.1, p.103-134.
Ghezelsofla Mohammadtaghi 2003, Art and policy, Research journal of humanities and social sciences, Issue.9-10, pp.213-234.
Ghayoumi Bidhendi Mehrdad 2008, Support for hidden angles in art history of Iran, Golestan Honar Journal, Issue.13, pp.5-7.
Molana Seyyed Hamid 2011, Recognizing, censure and reducing contradiction in insider culture, Monthly periodical of IRIB, Issue.54, pp.47-48.
Mirmohammad Sadeghi Hoseein 2009, Legal pluralism, Legal teachings, Issue.12, pp.3-13.
Vahid Majid 2004, Attitude on organization and its logic: 3 years with Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance(Research department), Journal of Faculty of law and political sciences, Issue.65, pp.227-215.
Varjavand Parviz 1997, Ministry of Culture and book censorship, Gozaresh Journal, Issue.81, pp.28-30.
Hadavand Mehdi 2009, Criterions of good administration and evolutions of administrative law: conceptual analysis, Legal research, Specific journal Issue.1, pp.63-120.
Names of selected documentary films of Fajr Festival was announced: From righthand to left-hand in Fajr festival, Etemad, 11th year, Issue.2866, Jan 6, 2014, p.12.
[Ali Janati:] These films were not produced in our age, Etemad, 11th year, Issue.2890, Feb 4, 2014, p.16.
Ayoubi: The cinema of Iran from basics to resistance style cinema, Etemad, 12th year, Issue.3081, Oct 12, 2014, p.8.
In memory of Seifollah Dad, Days with absence of Seifollah Dad, Etemad, 10th year, Issue.2453, July 26, 2021 p.11.
Hojatollah Ayoubi: We don’t permit for return of economic rent, Etemad, 11th year, Issue.2866, Jan 6, 2014, p.12.
Doulatabadi Mahmmoud: If it is not too late!, Etemad, 11th year, Issue.2871, Jan 12, 2014, p.16.
Ali Janati: The Minister of culture as narrated by IRIB, Etemad, 12th year, Issue.3050, Sep 4, 2014. p.20.
Interview with Mr. Seyyed Mohammad  Khatami, Attitude toward supreme Council of Cultural Revolution, Issue.1, 1985, pp.85 and 91.
Deputy of cultural affairs of Ministry of Culture: It is impossible to make order of literature, Etemad, 11th year, Issue.2982, June 14, 2014 p.16.
Aref: Artists are not employee of state, Bahar, June 6, 2013, p.9.
Statement of 280 cultural and artistic famous persons of acknowledging Aref, Bahar, June 13, 2013 p.12.
Letter of daughter of Alireza Eftekhari to Ezatollah Entezami: My father was cheated by these games, Shargh, 10th year, Issue.1737, May 20, 2013 pp.1 and 11.
Reaction of Shah Abadi [Cultural deputy of Minister of Culture] to rumor of cancelation of license for pop concert: Pop music is not paused, Tamasha, Issue.463, Dec 18, 2012 p.21.
Minister of Culture [Seyyed Mohammad Hosseini]: This year we have good films, Arman, Issue.2115, Jan 31, 2013 p.8.
The order art, Yes or not, Etemad, 11th year, Issue.2982, June 12, 2014 p.16.
Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Iran.
Goals and duties of Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance  act, 1986.
 
The Journal of Modern Research on Administrative Law
Volume 3, Issue 7 - Serial Number 7
Third year, 7th Issue, Summer 2021
July 2021
Pages 191-217

Files

History

  • Receive Date: 02 December 2020
  • Revise Date: 20 July 2021
  • Accept Date: 16 July 2021

Share

How to cite

Statistics